I've met several children with RTS who have the same problem as Maria: they can understand spoken language but they have difficulty speaking it. This is usually expressed as good receptive but poor expressive language skills.
In situations like these it's common for the experts (Educational Psychologist, Speech and Language Therapist) to recommend other modes of language expression (the jargon is augmentative and alternative communication, abbreviated to AAC) which include sign systems (like Makaton and Singalong) and symbolic systems (like PECS and Proloquo2go). These systems are not as nuanced as a full language but they do provide a basic means of communication. Also sign systems are much quicker to use than symbolic systems when communicating with someone.
It's quite common nowadays for parents to use baby sign language from the age of one onwards. This helps young childen express basic needs such as hunger, thirst and toilet well before they can speak. Maria was about three years old when she started to baby sign and was very keen to learn, picking up her first ten signs in less than thirty minutes. We used the inspirational Sing and Sign DVDs by Sasha Felix which teach a mixture of Makaton and Signalong signs. Maria and Isabella loved to watch these DVDs and Maria knew them backwards (she could turn her back to the TV and sign any bit of the video). It was no accident that I bought these DVDs; at the age of two I could sense Maria's need to express herself and by three years she was clearly getting frustrated. At age three she'd been babbling for over a year and was using gestures to communicate, so signing seemed a natural extension of this behaviour. Little did I realise just how important Makaton would become as Maria's first expressive language.
I knew from Cathy Stevens (2011) that at least 15% of adults with RTS develop no speech. At that time (2 to 4 years old) Maria was showing little aptitude for speech and so I decided to have a backup plan just in case she became one of the 15% that never learnt to speak. Baby signing followed by Makaton seemed like a good choice for now but what if Maria reached the age of six and still couldn't speak? Was she supposed to use Makaton for the rest of her life? Didn't Maria deserve to be taught a proper language to express herself? If so then which language should it be?
The main sign language of the UK is British Sign Language (BSL) but when I suggested using this to the 'experts' (the Educational Psychologist, the LEA Head of SEN and the London deaf school) they all said 'no' for different reasons.The Educational Psychologist thought it was the wrong choice and insisted it should be Makaton (but was sure Maria would speak anyway). The LEA Head of SEN told me that only deaf children are permitted access to BSL schools; and the London deaf school told me they only take deaf children.
All these opinions got me researching some of the sign systems and sign languages used by people in the UK to see which was the best choice for Maria in her later years, should she never develop speech.
Monday, 3 June 2013
What is the best school for Maria: mainstream or special?
The decision to send Maria to a Special School was much easier than I'd expected.
I'd been reading the book 'Working with Hannah: a special girl in a mainstream school' by Liz Wise and Chris Glass, and I was ready to fight for a place for Maria in one of our local mainstream schools.
One day in July 2012, we'd arranged two appointments that morning. The second was to meet with the Head of SEN to discuss Maria's Statement of SEN. Fortunately, just before that meeting Joan and I went to visit our local Special School. The deputy head showed us around and answered all our questions mainly with honesty but also with a touch of diplomacy.
The more I saw, the more impressed I became and soon realised that Maria would flourish in a place that completely understood her needs, without having to fight for concessions, provisions and equality.
By the time we arrived for the appointment with the Head of SEN, all I wanted was to get a place for Maria at the school. The deputy head told us of a shortage of places and how oversubscribed they were. To make things worse, we were applying late; I couldn't see how Maria would get a place.
After our meeting with the Head of SEN, he said he'd speak to the school. Within a week we received a letter offering us a place at the school! Maybe the Head of SEN wasn't all bad after all!
One year on as our intuitions about the school proved right. Maria has thrived and developed wonderfully. She's enjoyed every minute and there's no doubt it's the right place for her to be at present.
The school Ofsted reports only rated it as 'Good' but, according to the same report, parents rate it highly. I can see why; it's hard to imagine a better environment for Maria. As far as I'm concerned it's an 'Outstanding' school.
I feel a bit guilty because I've given the Head Teacher a hard time this year while I've learnt how the school system operates. The school has tried hard to improve its communication with parents and, one year on, I'm beginning to see the benefits of having made the right choice: the sheer joy on Maria's face when she goes to school each morning and returns home with stories of what happened that day (expressed in babble, English and Makaton) and Maria's significant educational achievements make us appreciate how much the school has done for her this year.
I'd been reading the book 'Working with Hannah: a special girl in a mainstream school' by Liz Wise and Chris Glass, and I was ready to fight for a place for Maria in one of our local mainstream schools.
One day in July 2012, we'd arranged two appointments that morning. The second was to meet with the Head of SEN to discuss Maria's Statement of SEN. Fortunately, just before that meeting Joan and I went to visit our local Special School. The deputy head showed us around and answered all our questions mainly with honesty but also with a touch of diplomacy.
The more I saw, the more impressed I became and soon realised that Maria would flourish in a place that completely understood her needs, without having to fight for concessions, provisions and equality.
By the time we arrived for the appointment with the Head of SEN, all I wanted was to get a place for Maria at the school. The deputy head told us of a shortage of places and how oversubscribed they were. To make things worse, we were applying late; I couldn't see how Maria would get a place.
After our meeting with the Head of SEN, he said he'd speak to the school. Within a week we received a letter offering us a place at the school! Maybe the Head of SEN wasn't all bad after all!
One year on as our intuitions about the school proved right. Maria has thrived and developed wonderfully. She's enjoyed every minute and there's no doubt it's the right place for her to be at present.
The school Ofsted reports only rated it as 'Good' but, according to the same report, parents rate it highly. I can see why; it's hard to imagine a better environment for Maria. As far as I'm concerned it's an 'Outstanding' school.
I feel a bit guilty because I've given the Head Teacher a hard time this year while I've learnt how the school system operates. The school has tried hard to improve its communication with parents and, one year on, I'm beginning to see the benefits of having made the right choice: the sheer joy on Maria's face when she goes to school each morning and returns home with stories of what happened that day (expressed in babble, English and Makaton) and Maria's significant educational achievements make us appreciate how much the school has done for her this year.
What are Maria's educational needs?
![]() |
| Teacher Maria |
That's the $64,000 question. The fact is that each child with RTS (or any other syndrome for that matter) is a unique person with unique challenges. Experts and school teachers are very good at recognising the common symptoms and applying remedies. Quite often techniques that work for one syndrome can be applied to another.
For example, many syndromes result in speech delay. The usual solution is to use several simultaneous methods of expressive communication: a manual system like Makaton together with a visual system like PECS and an oral system like Cued Articulation with speech therapy.
When this approach is extended even further to include areas like music, touch and body movement then the system is called Total Communication. The aim is to try every major method of expression to see which works best for that individual. Bear in mind that different solutions may be dominant at different stages of development.
For example, Maria used a manual system at the age of three but is progressing to an oral system now she is five. She uses visual systems mainly at school for organising her day, but for other children the visual system may be a vital entry point into communication.
Getting back to the question of Maria's educational needs. These were determined by a group of 'experts' specialising in different fields, who gave their opinion on Maria's current and future state. They made recommendations in their reports which fed into Maria's Special Educational Needs (SEN) statement, which has the status of a legal document, compeling the Local Education Authority (LEA) to provide the services that Maria needs at school.
For example, the first expert was a geneticist, who confirmed Maria's diagnosis of RTS. The next was the educational psychologist who assessed Maria's mental state and concluded she was delayed in specific areas, recommending, among other things, using Makaton; Maria was almost four years old and was about to start school. Then came the speech & language therapist with her report. Then the occupational therapist. Then the paediatrician who collated all of Maria's medical reports from other specialists, namely: the orthodontist (dentist), the gastroenterologist (throat and stomach), the ophthalmologist (eyesight), the audiologist (hearing), the kidney ultrasound specialist, the skin & eczema consultant, the cardiologist, the clinical imaging team (to check Maria's swallowing and gagging) and the orthopaedics consultant. Some of these appointments were attended several times, and that's not including all the times we attended the General Practitioner's (GP) clinic in order to be referred to these specialists!
All the reports fed into Maria's SEN statement, compiled initially by the Head of SEN at the LEA. He worked out what provisions Maria needed and sent us a copy of the first draft for approval. This is a crucial stage. Don't agree to this draft if you're not happy with the provisions. Normally the document will reflect the opinions of the experts, so unless you can find an expert to support your views then you'll find it difficult to simply insert your own comments in the crucial parts 2 and 3 of the Statement. We met up with the Head of SEN to discuss a few issues, particularly that of teaching Maria BSL rather than Makaton, but he wasn't sympathetic to our views and basically told us that BSL is only provided for children with severe hearing problems. Finally we agree some revisions to the statement and soon after received a copy of the Final Statement of Special Educational Needs. That was to become the document that would define what help Maria would get at school.
Of course the LEA is strapped for cash and won't give a child anything it doesn't deem essential. By essential they mean whatever the experts recommend. It's not that long ago that speech & language therapy (SALT) was viewed by them as unnecessary, After parents fought and won that battle, it then became the turn of the occupational therapist (OT) to establish their place. Now that both these services are more established (although Maria's Head Teacher told me the LEA only gives OT to autistic children at her school) there are other services that still need wide acceptance by the LEA; one is music therapy. Only in exceptional circumstances does the LEA fund this hocus-pocus treatment. In fact, the last time I spoke to the Head of SEN he told me that music therapy for Maria 'is not an educational need'. What did he mean by that? When I asked him, he simply dodged the question. He wasn't going to educate me sufficiently to allow me to challenge his view. I also knew that I would need a fairly strong argument to challenge his view at a Tribunal.
But what did he mean by 'not an educational need'? My guess is he meant that if it's not in Part 3 of the Statement of SEN then, by definition, it's not an educational need. The way to get it into Part 3 is to get an expert to make a recommendation that is accepted in Part 2 and then translated into an educational need in Part 3. This 'translation' is initially done by the Head of SEN but can be challenged at a Tribunal. Usually it doesn't get to that stage because the LEA thinks hard before letting it get that far. So, being a determined and switched-on parent is the only way to help your child. If you have the expert backup then don't take no for an answer.
Joan and I are the only true advocates of Maria. The school and the LEA have their own agendas; too often constrained by finances, their motives should always be questioned by parents.
Like all concerned parents, we observe Maria and take note of her needs and interests. This knowledge can be used to help motivate Maria to learn new things. Maria loves to dance and sing; this enthusiasm on Maria's part can be used to help develop her speech, her gross and fine motor skills and her attention span.
Sunday, 2 June 2013
What can we do to help Maria's attention deficit?
It's not that Maria can't spend quite substantial periods of time concentrating. She can watch a TV for an hour. She can play with her iPad for an hour easily. She can look at books for long stretches of up to half an hour. The problem is when you want her to do something that she doesn't. Trying to get her attention and concentrate on the task at hand can be difficult.
Clearly interest and motivation play a part - as with all of us - but somehow, Maria is too easily distracted and forgets or looses interest in what she was doing just a few moments earlier. This can be particularly frustrating when you're trying to get out of the house and you ask her to put on her coat or shoes. It can take ages before you finally grab her attention sufficiently for her to perform the task. It takes many requests and much patience before the task is completed.
Speaking to Prof. Chris Oliver at the recent RTS UK event in Northampton, he suggested reducing the number of distractions before requesting Maria to do something (i.e. switch off the TV, radio, Isabella, mummy, baby John, daddy etc.) and providing higher levels of reward (e.g. Maria has had some wet episodes recently so she currently expects jelly beans when she remembers to go to the toilet on time). Well, in the world of disabilities you have to be prepared to give it a go.
By the way, Chris also mentioned that the evidence points to a problem with 'working memory' in people with RTS. To explain working memory, imagine short-term memory where you're asked to process information immediately after recalling it e.g. remembering and recalling a telephone number and then being asked to say it backwards. It's not that people with RTS have particularly poor short-term memory or long-term memory (certainly Maria doesn't) but how that information can be processed.
Typically, when I ask Maria to put on her coat then she might start to do it, gets distracted, and subsequently forgets. With further prompting she'll ignore me until I remind her several more times; meanwhile she'll be focussed on something else. Eventually I'll remind her enough times and with enough emphasis that she finally does it, often under protest.
This tardiness may seem like stubbornness but here we have to be careful. Parents often like to take on the role of 'director', ordering around their children like a sergeant major. Certainly Joan and I do it occasionally, particularly when we're in a hurry. Maria is intelligent and gets pretty tired of being told what to do by her parents. If anyone did it to me I'd tell then to get lost!
The other day Maria was angry because I'd misunderstood some conflict between her and Isabella. She ran downstairs in protest and when I followed her she stood pointing at the door and shouted 'go' followed by 'silly old Farmer Ham' (the phrase is from one of her storybooks in which the crows poke fun at Farmer Ham until he gets his own back by dressing up as a scarecrow). I guess Maria was telling me I was stupid and didn't understand anything. Not bad for someone with expressive delay!
Clearly interest and motivation play a part - as with all of us - but somehow, Maria is too easily distracted and forgets or looses interest in what she was doing just a few moments earlier. This can be particularly frustrating when you're trying to get out of the house and you ask her to put on her coat or shoes. It can take ages before you finally grab her attention sufficiently for her to perform the task. It takes many requests and much patience before the task is completed.
Speaking to Prof. Chris Oliver at the recent RTS UK event in Northampton, he suggested reducing the number of distractions before requesting Maria to do something (i.e. switch off the TV, radio, Isabella, mummy, baby John, daddy etc.) and providing higher levels of reward (e.g. Maria has had some wet episodes recently so she currently expects jelly beans when she remembers to go to the toilet on time). Well, in the world of disabilities you have to be prepared to give it a go.
By the way, Chris also mentioned that the evidence points to a problem with 'working memory' in people with RTS. To explain working memory, imagine short-term memory where you're asked to process information immediately after recalling it e.g. remembering and recalling a telephone number and then being asked to say it backwards. It's not that people with RTS have particularly poor short-term memory or long-term memory (certainly Maria doesn't) but how that information can be processed.
Typically, when I ask Maria to put on her coat then she might start to do it, gets distracted, and subsequently forgets. With further prompting she'll ignore me until I remind her several more times; meanwhile she'll be focussed on something else. Eventually I'll remind her enough times and with enough emphasis that she finally does it, often under protest.
This tardiness may seem like stubbornness but here we have to be careful. Parents often like to take on the role of 'director', ordering around their children like a sergeant major. Certainly Joan and I do it occasionally, particularly when we're in a hurry. Maria is intelligent and gets pretty tired of being told what to do by her parents. If anyone did it to me I'd tell then to get lost!
The other day Maria was angry because I'd misunderstood some conflict between her and Isabella. She ran downstairs in protest and when I followed her she stood pointing at the door and shouted 'go' followed by 'silly old Farmer Ham' (the phrase is from one of her storybooks in which the crows poke fun at Farmer Ham until he gets his own back by dressing up as a scarecrow). I guess Maria was telling me I was stupid and didn't understand anything. Not bad for someone with expressive delay!
Thursday, 16 May 2013
Why does Maria gorge and vomit?
![]() |
| Gorgeous Maria |
RTS children are typically below average height and some suffer from being overweight or obese. Chances are the overweight problem is down to diet but you have to watch the vomiting in case it leads to malnutrition.
As Maria gets older she's managed to control the choking and vomiting. We encourage this by reminding her to bite and chew her food before swallowing. We also point out when she has stuffed her mouth with too much food. She's making slow but steady progress in all these areas and her behaviour is much influenced by her peers at school. But it would seem she behaves differently at school than at home. For example, the school maintains they never see her gorging when she eats her lunch, whereas she does it all the time at home. Curious!
Wednesday, 15 May 2013
Can Maria see and hear normally?
Maria has seen her opthalmologist twice now and they feel she has good eyesight. It helps that she can sign in Makaton when viewing the animal charts. She could even use the alphabetic charts if asked, as her knowledge of the alphabet and numbers up to 13 is very good. She can not only pronounce the sounds but can even recognise the written forms of the letters and numbers.
Maria's also visited her audiologist four times and had fairly thorough hearing tests. They feel her hearing is good, however there is some loss in the 4 kHz region owing to glue ear. This prevents her hearing sibilant sounds properly, so her spoken 's' sounds tend to be be unclear.
I made sure that both the opthalmologist and audiologist were of the paediatric variety. I didn't want Maria to suffer from the fear I had of dentists as a child. This probably traces back to when I was a child visiting our family dentist and being placed under a general anaesthetic. When I woke up I discovered he'd removed the wrong three teeth. I was probably around 6 years old. The next time I visited the dentist I screamed the place down. It was another 12 years before I went to a dentist again.
Maria's also visited her audiologist four times and had fairly thorough hearing tests. They feel her hearing is good, however there is some loss in the 4 kHz region owing to glue ear. This prevents her hearing sibilant sounds properly, so her spoken 's' sounds tend to be be unclear.
I made sure that both the opthalmologist and audiologist were of the paediatric variety. I didn't want Maria to suffer from the fear I had of dentists as a child. This probably traces back to when I was a child visiting our family dentist and being placed under a general anaesthetic. When I woke up I discovered he'd removed the wrong three teeth. I was probably around 6 years old. The next time I visited the dentist I screamed the place down. It was another 12 years before I went to a dentist again.
Friday, 10 May 2013
Does Maria need any surgery?
![]() | |
| Nurse Maria |
Maria wouldn't drink the barium solution directly but I knew she loves hot chocolate milk. Unfortunately the department didn't have any so the radiologists scurried around for about fifteen minutes and eventually tracked some down. I was impressed by their tenacity.
Once we made the hot barium-chocolate concoction, Maria refused to drink it lying down so we sat her up and turned the machine at right-angles to see the image of her throat. Everyone in the room except Maria was wearing a protective lead-lined jacket. The barium made a mess when spilt on hands and clothes and was difficult to clean off, leaving a white stain similar to calamine lotion.
At first I thought the barium was radioactive but when I checked on Wikipedia I realised that it wasn't. However the fluoroscope contains an x-ray source, so exposure to children and pregnant women should only occur as a last resort.
Once we got the results, the radiologists said they couldn't see any obvious abnormalities with Maria's swallowing. The follow-up appointment with a gastroenterologist concluded that it was safer not to operate. He believed that Maria would learn to cope in time, and it seems he was right.
Nowadays, when Maria shows signs of choking then she adopts a special breathing posture, taking deep breaths through her nose and mouth. She even demonstrated it to her mummy the other day to suggest that she calm down after becoming stressed!
A more common form of surgery for RTS children is to the thumbs and big toes (halluces). Fortunately Maria hasn't needed this type of surgery.
Maria's dentist is on the lookout for talon cusps, which may appear in a few years. This would require surgery too but, fingers crossed, she might never develop them.
At first I thought the barium was radioactive but when I checked on Wikipedia I realised that it wasn't. However the fluoroscope contains an x-ray source, so exposure to children and pregnant women should only occur as a last resort.
Once we got the results, the radiologists said they couldn't see any obvious abnormalities with Maria's swallowing. The follow-up appointment with a gastroenterologist concluded that it was safer not to operate. He believed that Maria would learn to cope in time, and it seems he was right.
Nowadays, when Maria shows signs of choking then she adopts a special breathing posture, taking deep breaths through her nose and mouth. She even demonstrated it to her mummy the other day to suggest that she calm down after becoming stressed!
A more common form of surgery for RTS children is to the thumbs and big toes (halluces). Fortunately Maria hasn't needed this type of surgery.
Maria's dentist is on the lookout for talon cusps, which may appear in a few years. This would require surgery too but, fingers crossed, she might never develop them.
Wednesday, 1 May 2013
What therapies does Maria need?
![]() |
| Fairy Isabella |
First, a good school teacher who can sign in Makaton is a great starting point; someone who has a rapport with Maria and can implement a national curriculum and instructions from a therapist. There are several therapists encouraging Maria to concentrate and verbalize:
1. a Speech & Language Therapist to help Maria articulate and form expressive language.
2. an Occupational Therapist to help Maria with fine motor skills and attention to tasks; the therapist believes that attention is enhanced following a period of exercise.
3. a Music Therapist to encourage Maria to articulate words through the melody and rhythm of music and song. This method draws on Maria's love of music and movement. I've asked the therapist to look into applying a method similar to Melodic Intonation Therapy, which should help with articulation. The method is not well-known here in the UK so I've supplied our therapist with papers I found referenced in the Wikipedia article.
For now, Maria is learning Makaton but I'd prefer BSL instead. That's why I'm learning BSL myself and encouraging Maria to watch BSL videos at home. Signing is Maria's primary expressive language and her safety net; currently speech supplements her signing but there is growing evidence that it will soon overtake her need to sign.
Saturday, 13 April 2013
Is there anything we can do to help Maria's development?
The first thing we asked ourselves was 'what can we do to help?' My initial reaction was to find out as much as possible about RTS. It didn't take long. A months research just about covered everything on the Internet because there isn't much out there on RTS. In order to get some kind of answers I had to be content with literature on more common diseases, like Down Syndrome (DS). A case in point is that of reading; there are no books on teaching children with RTS to read, so I bought 'Teaching Reading to Children with Down Syndrome' by Patricia Logan Oelwein. To encourage Maria to speak I bought books from The Hanen Program ('It Takes Two to Talk' and 'You Make The Difference'). To help Maria with articulation I bought 'Cued Articulation' by Jane Passy. And just in case Maria never became fully verbal then I bought 'Literacy Skill Development' by Leslie Broun & Patricia Oelwein. Trying to find time to read all these books, never mind putting them into practice when you have a full-time job, is another matter. Fortunately, Maria started a Special School last September and they already use the techniques covered by some of these books.
Trying to be the teacher as well as the parent is not really something I find I have time for during the week. I leave for work at 7 am and return home at around 6:30 pm, giving me an hour to eat dinner with the family before getting the children ready for bed; they're usually asleep by 8:30 pm. To compensate, I try to do something with the family at the weekends, but this will become more complicated when Joan returns to work from maternity leave. So I've resigned myself to dealing with the administrative issues, leaving Joan to handle most of Maria's teaching and clinical sessions.
If I can't do the work myself then I can at least coordinate with those who do, which includes Maria's clinical appointments, school meetings and the Local Education Authority (LEA). Much of my time is spent making sure the school implements what the LEA has stated in Maria's Statement of Educational Needs (SEN). Periodically the SEN is reviewed by the LEA, in which case I need to ensure the appropriate 'experts' report on Maria's progress, ideally stating in their report the number of hours of treatment Maria needs in any given area, such as Speech & Language Therapy or Occupational Therapy. Currently I'm trying to introduce Music Therapy into Maria's school activities by persuading the LEA to pay for the sessions.
I found an amazing resource about a year ago on a US website called Unique which offered an entire school curriculum for disabled children. At a cost of around £300 per year it provides everything you need to know in order to teach your child at home. I particularly like the quantitative method of assessing progress although I can't say I've actually used the website much since Maria started at Special School. They do similar stuff in the UK but use a qualitative method of assessment which, in my view, is never going to be as objective. Maybe the schools know something that I don't. If you are interested in the course then be aware that the teaching material assumes an intimate knowledge of American culture; I'm from the UK and I was surprised how much I didn't know. In a curious way, I found this made the course more interesting for me!
Maria's development is obviously an ongoing process and we're going to spend the rest of our lives helping her to reach her maximum potential.
Trying to be the teacher as well as the parent is not really something I find I have time for during the week. I leave for work at 7 am and return home at around 6:30 pm, giving me an hour to eat dinner with the family before getting the children ready for bed; they're usually asleep by 8:30 pm. To compensate, I try to do something with the family at the weekends, but this will become more complicated when Joan returns to work from maternity leave. So I've resigned myself to dealing with the administrative issues, leaving Joan to handle most of Maria's teaching and clinical sessions.
If I can't do the work myself then I can at least coordinate with those who do, which includes Maria's clinical appointments, school meetings and the Local Education Authority (LEA). Much of my time is spent making sure the school implements what the LEA has stated in Maria's Statement of Educational Needs (SEN). Periodically the SEN is reviewed by the LEA, in which case I need to ensure the appropriate 'experts' report on Maria's progress, ideally stating in their report the number of hours of treatment Maria needs in any given area, such as Speech & Language Therapy or Occupational Therapy. Currently I'm trying to introduce Music Therapy into Maria's school activities by persuading the LEA to pay for the sessions.
I found an amazing resource about a year ago on a US website called Unique which offered an entire school curriculum for disabled children. At a cost of around £300 per year it provides everything you need to know in order to teach your child at home. I particularly like the quantitative method of assessing progress although I can't say I've actually used the website much since Maria started at Special School. They do similar stuff in the UK but use a qualitative method of assessment which, in my view, is never going to be as objective. Maybe the schools know something that I don't. If you are interested in the course then be aware that the teaching material assumes an intimate knowledge of American culture; I'm from the UK and I was surprised how much I didn't know. In a curious way, I found this made the course more interesting for me!
Maria's development is obviously an ongoing process and we're going to spend the rest of our lives helping her to reach her maximum potential.
Thursday, 11 April 2013
Will our daughter ever learn to speak?
| Ladies-in-waiting |
I raised this issue with Maria's Educational Psychologist (EP) who, despite having no professional experience of RTS, felt that Maria would eventually speak given her current drive to communicate and recommended Makaton in the meantime. I said okay but - recalling the statistics in Stevens paper - wasn't so sure that she would speak. I said that Makaton is fine up to the age of six but that Makaton wasn't actually a language and if Maria still wasn't speaking by that age then she should be taught a language other than English to express herself with; clearly this should be a sign language and since we live in the UK then it must be British Sign Language (BSL).
Our Local Education Authority (LEA) wasn't prepared to offer Maria BSL as part of her school curriculum and the 'local' BSL school in London only accepted deaf children. And so I reached my first impasse with the LEA; it was to be Makaton or nothing at school. The opinion of the EP was final and parents had no influence on their judgement when drawing-up a final SEN. I couldn't argue because Maria was still only four years old and two years from my rather arbitrary six year mark. I'd chosen 'six' because I couldn't imagine going through life much later than that without being able to fully express myself.
Coming back to Maria, I found that regardless of the communication medium, she seemed unable or unwilling to express herself. We tried a 'speech' system approach and a 'non-speech' system approach, namely Makaton signing and the Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) iPad application Proloquo2go. Maria learnt to sign Makaton very well but failed to use it to express herself. Regarding Proloquo2go, she only ever used it once to express a need; the rest of the time she played with it, listening to the word associated with each symbol. I wondered if she was ever going to stop throwing temper tantrums and learn to use these tools for self expression.
Maria is now five and since starting reception class in her new 'special' school she has acquired a larger spoken vocabulary. She regularly surprises us with new words we hadn't heard before. It can be very difficult to understand many of these words because of her articulation (aggravated by glue ear which affects the hearing of sibilant sounds; sure enough, Maria has trouble articulating 's' sounds) so it remains to be seen if her speech develops to become fully intelligible.
Since the age of two Maria has communicated by getting excited and babbling. Since the age of three she's included some Makaton signs. Since the age of five she's included some English words. Currently we're trying to encourage Maria to verbalise (speak) her vocalisations (babbling) by interrupting the babbling and asking her to 'say' something. We tell her that we don't understand and remind her to use words instead of babbling. It's a slow process but it seems effective.
More recently she's started to create some spontaneous sentences. The longest we've heard so far is a five-words, although she typically uses only two or three words. For example: 'Good morning', 'Maria beautiful', 'Maria naughty girl', 'Hi how are you' and 'Mummy tidy up bed room'. I'd estimate that Maria uses no more than 30 words spontaneously (without prompting). As a five year old she probably knows around 2500 words, meaning she's using 1.2% of her vocabulary to express herself with, so I believe she's still caught in a communication trap, especially when I compare her language abilities with three year old Isabella.
Looking back when Maria was three, I tried teaching her some Makaton signs. She picked up the first ten signs I taught her in less than 30 minutes. I was both surprised and delighted. I realised how desperate Maria was to express herself and how much her articulation and speech processing was holding her back.
When she was three years and five months old I bought her the first of the Sing & Sign DVDs (compatible with Makaton and Signalong). She loved it and almost wore it out through watching it hundreds of times. After a while she knew the DVD so well that she could turn her back to the TV and perform all the signs and gestures in sync with the picture.
Maria progressed to Makaton by watching the children's TV show Something Special on the BBC CBeebies channel. The lack of Makaton books got me looking at BSL books instead. Before long Maria and Isabella were both singing and signing songs in BSL as well as praying in BSL before they went to bed.
More recently I decided to learn BSL properly and bought some BSL videos which I placed on our two iPads. I soon found both girls watching these, which surprised me because I expected they'd want to watch the more entertaining Sing & Sign videos instead. It's difficult to say if their motivation is to watch something new or to learn something new (probably both).
Isabella watches these videos but doesn't sign now that she can talk. Most of the time Maria doesn't sign either when watching the videos but this doesn't mean she's not learning the signs. Ask her any of the signs afterwards and she'll demonstrate them to you; so her short-term memory seems to be pretty intact for this type of task.
The result of all this apparently passive watching is that Maria knows more Makaton and BSL than Joan and me. At her most stunning, Maria has twice performed a simultaneous translation into Makaton as we read her bedtime story book; she found it amusing but we found it amazing!
As an aside, a few weeks ago it was Easter and we were about to give Maria and Isabella a chocolate Easter egg. Seizing the opportunity to sign with Maria (an opportunity I often forget), I recalled the Makaton for 'chocolate' but realised I didn't know the sign for 'egg'. I asked Maria to show me and she signed something that neither Joan nor I recognised. We looked at one another and wondered if she was bluffing. I checked in our Makaton and BSL dictionaries and sure enough she was absolutely right; hers was the Makaton sign. Curiously the BSL sign for 'egg' is similar but not identical, which is strange because Makaton claims to be based on BSL but more on that topic in a coming post.
One day I wondered to myself: what if IQ tests were issued in sign language. What IQ would I have in a world that judged me on my ability to communicate through manual signing?
Sunday, 17 March 2013
What should I know about RTS?
What should I know about RTS? Quite a bit as it happens. From the perspective of Maria, there are two broad categories: physical issues and mental issues.
Physically, Maria is going to need a lifelong program of continual monitoring for well known symptoms associated with RTS. This list of potential symptoms is quite long.
Now I know from personal experience that when you make lists of things then it can make things look much worse than they really are. If I were to draw up a list of all the ailments I might potentially get from then it'd be pretty long and bleak. Fortunately, in the case of RTS then it's a list of quite well defined symptoms, so all I need to do is to be vigilant in recognising the symptoms when they occur and to take make sure Maria gets regular checkups in all the risk areas.
When examining the list of symptoms, it's helpful to know what percentage of the RTS population actually develop any given symptom. Ideally, this should be compared to the risk associated with a "normal" population. It's also useful to know when the risk is greatest, so you can be better prepared to spot the first signs.
For example, a "talon cusp" is a potential symptom of RTS but it doesn't normally appear until the child's permanent teeth start at the age of six onwards, so don't expect to see one in the early years (as I did).
The two best sources of medical advice on RTS symptoms and their timeline are:
1. the RTS Medical Guidelines by Wiley (2003)
2. the RTS Management Guidelines by Hennekam 2010)
Keep these papers to hand; re-read them from time to time and ask all the doctors who treat your child if they've read both these papers. Maria's orthodontist implied that he knew all about RTS because he'd treated six RTS children over the past twenty years. He wanted to discharge Maria after seeing her at the age of 4 years and 9 months but I argued that this was contrary to the advice given in one of the two papers. It turned out he'd never heard of these papers, so I emailed him the details when I got home.
Knowledge is empowering and if you know more about RTS than your doctors (and you probably will) then you can help protect your child by making them aware of RTS-specific issues. For example, if Maria ever needed to go under a general anaesthetic then I know - thanks to these papers - that I need to warn the anaesthetist that because of Maria's RTS condition, she might have a collapsible windpipe and that special measures may be needed to bring her in and out of consciousness (details are given in one of these papers). Just imagine what could happen if you weren't there to forewarn them.
How about the mental issues of RTS? Well, that's a bit more tricky because at present nobody really knows how the mind and brain work normally, let alone abnormally. There's never been a shortage of theories or 'models' but nobody has proposed a holistic model of the brain that predictive and useful. Until that happens then I'm afraid the 'experts' are unlikely to commit themselves. You'll notice this by the distinct lack of advice you'll get on so many of the important issues. The only thing to do is talk to others who've tackled similar problems to see what solutions they've come up with.
For example, I'm worried about how we're going to teach Maria to read. Well, there aren't any books on the market that cover reading for RTS children, so instead I've had to look at books like 'Teaching Reading to Children with Down Syndrome' by Patricia Logan Oelwein. You just have to use the best material you can get your hands on. One complication is that Down Syndrome is associated with short-term memory deficit whereas Rubinstein-Taybi Syndrome is associated with long-term memory problems, so I can't be sure the books approach will work for Maria. The Special School that Maria attends think they have a solution through their policy of continual reinforcement, meaning that if they keep reminding children then both long and short-term memory needs are covered.
There's one final thing you should know about RTS. How will you and your partner cope with the news that your child has RTS? In case you think your doctor has the answer then let me tell you that this issue isn't even on their radar. Joan and I weren't offered any kind of counselling to address the issue; we were left to deal with the fallout by ourselves - and you already know from my earlier post what a hash we made of it during that first week. In short, the trauma I felt that week was akin to the bereavement of a close friend. Fortunately I'm pretty level-headed and so the following week I woke out of my zombie state and started work on how to deal with this situation. Notice I said 'I' and not 'we'. Emotionally, Joan lagged behind by several months, unwilling to come to terms with the diagnosis. Even now, after two years, she admits that she still hasn't accepted the diagnosis.
I was frustrated because I needed to talk to someone who knew all about RTS but nobody was available. Professor Raoul Hennekam (the authority on RTS) had left Great Ormond Street Hospital in London and returned to the Netherlands, so there was no expert left to discuss Maria's prognosis. RTS is so rare that you're very lucky to find another case in your vicinity. Joan and I live in London and our Social Services told us there was one other family in the Borough with an RTS child. We had no way of contacting them. Fortunately we followed the advice of our geneticist and joined the national RTS UK group. We felt very much at home with people who knew all about RTS and were prepared to share their deeply felt experiences. Joan and I were a lot happier after that; we no longer felt alone.
Physically, Maria is going to need a lifelong program of continual monitoring for well known symptoms associated with RTS. This list of potential symptoms is quite long.
Now I know from personal experience that when you make lists of things then it can make things look much worse than they really are. If I were to draw up a list of all the ailments I might potentially get from then it'd be pretty long and bleak. Fortunately, in the case of RTS then it's a list of quite well defined symptoms, so all I need to do is to be vigilant in recognising the symptoms when they occur and to take make sure Maria gets regular checkups in all the risk areas.
When examining the list of symptoms, it's helpful to know what percentage of the RTS population actually develop any given symptom. Ideally, this should be compared to the risk associated with a "normal" population. It's also useful to know when the risk is greatest, so you can be better prepared to spot the first signs.
For example, a "talon cusp" is a potential symptom of RTS but it doesn't normally appear until the child's permanent teeth start at the age of six onwards, so don't expect to see one in the early years (as I did).
The two best sources of medical advice on RTS symptoms and their timeline are:
1. the RTS Medical Guidelines by Wiley (2003)
2. the RTS Management Guidelines by Hennekam 2010)
Keep these papers to hand; re-read them from time to time and ask all the doctors who treat your child if they've read both these papers. Maria's orthodontist implied that he knew all about RTS because he'd treated six RTS children over the past twenty years. He wanted to discharge Maria after seeing her at the age of 4 years and 9 months but I argued that this was contrary to the advice given in one of the two papers. It turned out he'd never heard of these papers, so I emailed him the details when I got home.
Knowledge is empowering and if you know more about RTS than your doctors (and you probably will) then you can help protect your child by making them aware of RTS-specific issues. For example, if Maria ever needed to go under a general anaesthetic then I know - thanks to these papers - that I need to warn the anaesthetist that because of Maria's RTS condition, she might have a collapsible windpipe and that special measures may be needed to bring her in and out of consciousness (details are given in one of these papers). Just imagine what could happen if you weren't there to forewarn them.
![]() |
| Maria sucks |
For example, I'm worried about how we're going to teach Maria to read. Well, there aren't any books on the market that cover reading for RTS children, so instead I've had to look at books like 'Teaching Reading to Children with Down Syndrome' by Patricia Logan Oelwein. You just have to use the best material you can get your hands on. One complication is that Down Syndrome is associated with short-term memory deficit whereas Rubinstein-Taybi Syndrome is associated with long-term memory problems, so I can't be sure the books approach will work for Maria. The Special School that Maria attends think they have a solution through their policy of continual reinforcement, meaning that if they keep reminding children then both long and short-term memory needs are covered.
There's one final thing you should know about RTS. How will you and your partner cope with the news that your child has RTS? In case you think your doctor has the answer then let me tell you that this issue isn't even on their radar. Joan and I weren't offered any kind of counselling to address the issue; we were left to deal with the fallout by ourselves - and you already know from my earlier post what a hash we made of it during that first week. In short, the trauma I felt that week was akin to the bereavement of a close friend. Fortunately I'm pretty level-headed and so the following week I woke out of my zombie state and started work on how to deal with this situation. Notice I said 'I' and not 'we'. Emotionally, Joan lagged behind by several months, unwilling to come to terms with the diagnosis. Even now, after two years, she admits that she still hasn't accepted the diagnosis.
I was frustrated because I needed to talk to someone who knew all about RTS but nobody was available. Professor Raoul Hennekam (the authority on RTS) had left Great Ormond Street Hospital in London and returned to the Netherlands, so there was no expert left to discuss Maria's prognosis. RTS is so rare that you're very lucky to find another case in your vicinity. Joan and I live in London and our Social Services told us there was one other family in the Borough with an RTS child. We had no way of contacting them. Fortunately we followed the advice of our geneticist and joined the national RTS UK group. We felt very much at home with people who knew all about RTS and were prepared to share their deeply felt experiences. Joan and I were a lot happier after that; we no longer felt alone.
Sunday, 10 March 2013
Is there a cure for RTS?
| 'Wild-type' Maria |
1. read the latest research literature and know what's on the horizon.
2. keep abreast of clinical trials and see what drugs are being currently tested or what the outcome was.
3. find which pharmaceutical drugs are available and contact your doctor.
Alternatively, you can let others do the donkey work and just visit your geneticist annually to find out about the latest treatments. Don't be like some carers and stop visiting your geneticist. And keeping a watchful eye on the scene still seems like a good idea to me. Your support group should be doing this too so stay in touch.
In this post, I'm going to review the research that helped me answer my questions. Some research papers need an advanced knowledge of biology, chemistry and statistics. I'm rusty on all three counts but I'll get better. You don't have to understand every word; the abstract, introduction and discussion are usually sufficient, especially if you find the paper heavy going.
A brief note on terminology: It's conventional to write human gene names in capital italics (e.g. CREBBP) and human protein names in regular capitals (e.g. CREBBP). Similarly, animal gene names are in lowercase italics with a capital initial letter (e.g. Crebbp) and animal protein names are in regular lowercase with an capital initial letter (e.g. Crebbp). You'll also find that gene names can have synonyms; for example, CBP means CREBBP and p300 means EP300. You've probably already realised that RTS is often written as RSTS.
Finally, you'll need a good genetics dictionary; I use the Talking Genetics Glossary or the Genetics Home Reference Glossary.
I'll start by looking at the most important RTS research literature and summarise what's happened over the past few decades in the fields of medicine, biology, psychology and education. The most prolific area is biology, followed by medicine. There are very few papers that address the psychology of RTS and none that I've found on the education of RTS children, so instead I've chosen some classic papers on the education of children with developmental delay:
Medicine
1963: Jack Rubinstein and Hooshang Taybi discovered a new syndrome because of some common characteristics, including short and broad thumbs and toes, "odd" facial features and mental retardation (yes, these were the days when "imbecile" (IQ of 26 - 50) and "moron" (IQ of 51-70) were medical terms).2003: M Shevell and colleagues review the scientific and clinical literature to determine how to evaluate a child with global development delay. They explain that the term 'global development delay' is restricted to children under the age of 5, whereas 'mental retardation' is reserved for older children for whom IQ assessment is more reliable and valid.
2003: Gregory O'Brien tells us that the intellectual disability in RTS ranges from mild to moderate and severe. The psychiatric disturbances in RTS are mainly mood disturbances. That RTS is a non-progressive syndrome, meaning that it doesn't get worse during the lifetime of the person. And finally, the life expectancy of RTS is normal (age 70), subject to occasional cardiac complications and brain tumours.
2011: Cathy A Stevens and colleagues conducted the first survey of RTS adults, mostly living in the US. It covered medical issues, education, independence and behaviour. The most common medical problems were short stature, obesity, visual difficulties, keloids, eating problems, spine curvature and joint problems. Educationally, the adults had moderate mental retardation but most achieved some degree of independence in communication and self-care. Many participated in supported work activities. They found one-third of those surveyed had some decreased abilities over time. Behaviour problems were common and often worsened with age. Very few saw a geneticist as adults. The survey recommends that long-term involvement with geneticists and adult education primary care providers may help with many of the challenges facing adults with RTS and their families. On the topic of communication, 41% of RTS adults were found to be conversational; the remaining 56% weren't (they communicated using short phrases (33%), single words (3%), signing (12%), words and signs (5%) or speech-assisted devices (3%)). I notice that 3% of this population are unaccounted for.
Biology
1995: Fred Petrij and colleagues show that RTS is caused by mutations in the CREBBP gene. Remember that chromosomes come in pairs, half from the mother and half from the father; the same applies to genes. Petrij proposes that RTS is caused by the loss of function in one half of the CREBBP gene (a haplo-insufficiency mechanism). They note that although the EP300 gene is functionally similar to CREBBP, it is incapable of compensating for the CREBBP haplo-insufficiency.
1999: Yuichi Oike and colleagues genetically engineer mice with a insertional mutation in the Crebbp gene. They find the mice develop RTS symptoms: slow body and bone growth, underdeveloped jaw bones with a narrow palate, heart problems, skeletal defects and long-term memory deficit; short-term memory appears normal. The RTS symptoms are thought to be caused by the inhibiting effect of the truncated Crebbp gene (a dominant-negative mechanism).
2004: Edward Korzus, Michael Rosenfeld and Mark Mayford remind us that the transcription coactivator CREBBP together with the transcription factor CREB work together to control gene expression. But CREBBP is also an histone acetyltransferase (HAT) and it can acetylate (switch on) histones in neurons. By engineering mice with a Crebbp gene that blocks HAT activity in adults, they managed to show that Crebbp is an active component in memory formation. They found that the new gene caused long-term memory deficit without affecting new information or short-term memory. This establishes that HAT activity is critical for forming long-term memory. The effect in the mice was reversed by administering a histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor called Trichostatin A (TSA).
2005: Jeroen Roelfsema, Raoul Hennekam and their colleagues show that mutations in the EP300 gene causes RTS in humans.
2005: Barbara Monti and colleagues show that repeated (sub-chronic) doses of Rolipram to rats enhances memory retention and slows down extinction of conditioned fear.
2008: K Rutten and colleagues administer repeated (sub-chronic) doses of Rolipram to rats and demonstrate that long-term memory is improved.
2010: O Bartsch and colleagues studied two families with inherited RTS traits. Their findings confirm that the HAT domain is crucial to RTS and that variable expression and somatic mosaicism contribute to the observable differences in RTS.
2010: Guiquan Chen and colleagues show that in mice the Crebbp protein plays a crucial role in the formation of short-term memory as well as long-term memory, object-recognition memory, spatial learning and spatial memory.
2012: J P Lopez-Atalaya and colleagues show that RTS is caused in humans by a deficit in the acetylation of the H2A and H2B histones. Interestingly, the deficit is reversed by treatment of human cells with a histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor called Trichostatin A (TSA) but unfortunately this has noxious side-effects on humans. Epigenetic drugs (epi-drugs) like Trichostatin A are currently being tested by the pharmaceutical industry for the treatment of cancer and brain disease. A spin-off of this research might provide a treatment for RTS.
2015: Hee Jeong Yoo and colleagues describe a young Korean girl with RTS and ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) whose condition was studied using Whole Exome Sequencing (WES). They found not only a de novo (non-inherited) frameshift mutation in the CREBBP gene but also de novo missense mutations in the TNC gene on chromosome 9 and the IGFALS gene on chromosome 16. They suggest the TNC gene is responsible for the neurological characteristics of RTS and the IGFALS gene is responsible for growth retardation in RTS.
2004: Elizabeth Kay-Raining Bird and colleagues studied children with Down Syndrome (DS) and found they were capable of learning two languages without any detrimental effects, although individuals were variable in abilities.1999: Yuichi Oike and colleagues genetically engineer mice with a insertional mutation in the Crebbp gene. They find the mice develop RTS symptoms: slow body and bone growth, underdeveloped jaw bones with a narrow palate, heart problems, skeletal defects and long-term memory deficit; short-term memory appears normal. The RTS symptoms are thought to be caused by the inhibiting effect of the truncated Crebbp gene (a dominant-negative mechanism).
2004: Edward Korzus, Michael Rosenfeld and Mark Mayford remind us that the transcription coactivator CREBBP together with the transcription factor CREB work together to control gene expression. But CREBBP is also an histone acetyltransferase (HAT) and it can acetylate (switch on) histones in neurons. By engineering mice with a Crebbp gene that blocks HAT activity in adults, they managed to show that Crebbp is an active component in memory formation. They found that the new gene caused long-term memory deficit without affecting new information or short-term memory. This establishes that HAT activity is critical for forming long-term memory. The effect in the mice was reversed by administering a histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor called Trichostatin A (TSA).
| Princess Maria of Sodor |
2005: Jeroen Roelfsema, Raoul Hennekam and their colleagues show that mutations in the EP300 gene causes RTS in humans.
2005: Barbara Monti and colleagues show that repeated (sub-chronic) doses of Rolipram to rats enhances memory retention and slows down extinction of conditioned fear.
2008: K Rutten and colleagues administer repeated (sub-chronic) doses of Rolipram to rats and demonstrate that long-term memory is improved.
2010: O Bartsch and colleagues studied two families with inherited RTS traits. Their findings confirm that the HAT domain is crucial to RTS and that variable expression and somatic mosaicism contribute to the observable differences in RTS.
2010: Guiquan Chen and colleagues show that in mice the Crebbp protein plays a crucial role in the formation of short-term memory as well as long-term memory, object-recognition memory, spatial learning and spatial memory.
2012: J P Lopez-Atalaya and colleagues show that RTS is caused in humans by a deficit in the acetylation of the H2A and H2B histones. Interestingly, the deficit is reversed by treatment of human cells with a histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor called Trichostatin A (TSA) but unfortunately this has noxious side-effects on humans. Epigenetic drugs (epi-drugs) like Trichostatin A are currently being tested by the pharmaceutical industry for the treatment of cancer and brain disease. A spin-off of this research might provide a treatment for RTS.
2015: Hee Jeong Yoo and colleagues describe a young Korean girl with RTS and ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) whose condition was studied using Whole Exome Sequencing (WES). They found not only a de novo (non-inherited) frameshift mutation in the CREBBP gene but also de novo missense mutations in the TNC gene on chromosome 9 and the IGFALS gene on chromosome 16. They suggest the TNC gene is responsible for the neurological characteristics of RTS and the IGFALS gene is responsible for growth retardation in RTS.
Psychology
2007: Elizabeth Kay-Raining Bird writes more extensively to include children with intellectual disabilities learning two or more languages. She gives some positive and encouraging advice. [So, if you're from an RTS family that needs to speak several languages then go for it. In my experience, having been brought up speaking Polish first then English, I see my knowledge of these two languages as a continuum; depending on who I'm talking to, I'll pick words from one or both languages].
2009: S Carvey and B May Bernhardt studied communication in a 4-year old RTS child. The child made 6 communicative acts per minute. Commenting was the most common type of act, followed by requesting and then expressing feelings and attitudes. Vocalisation (making noises) was the most common mode of communication, followed by emerging linguistic skills (signs, single word verbalisation). The recommended intervention is parent training together with speech & language therapy focussing on early lexical and phonological development. Communication could be helped by modelling and encouraging communication in situations where communication is little used (e.g. during mealtime or during play or reading a book). Puzzle-playing and book-reading might be structured to encourage more child initiations and fewer adult questions.
2012: Jane Waite examines in her thesis the relationship between executive function development and repetitive behaviour in RTS. Incidentally, Waite also defines a relationship between the mental age (MA) of an RTS child and the chronological age (CA):
MA = 0.27 * CA + 4.18. For example, this formula predicts that Maria, aged 63 months (CA) to date has an approximate mental age of 21 months (MA). To validate this figure I looked at Maria's SEN Annual Review just released by her special school. My problem is which figure in the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) review should I take as representative of her mental age (MA)? Is it the "Communication and Language" figure of 16-26 months for "Speaking" or is it 30-50 months for both "Understanding" and "Listening and attention"? Maybe I should be looking elsewhere at the "Personal, Social and Emotional Development" figure of 22-36 months for "Making relationships" or perhaps 30-50 months for both "Self-confidence and self-awareness" and for "Managing feelings and behaviour"? Are we asking too much to believe that just one number can represent all dimensions of our daughter Maria?
Education
1999: Shari Brand Robertson and Susan Ellis Weismer studied late-talking but otherwise normal toddlers. At the time this paper was written, clinical management of late-talking toddlers was unclear. The paper describes two schools of thought on how to tackle language delay: the "early intervention" and the "wait-and-see" approaches. This study tested the "early intervention" approach on several linguistic and social skills. They found their intervention not only improved language skills but also social skills as well as parental perception, which implied lower parental stress.
2002: Paul J Yoder and Steven F Warren studied children with intellectual disabilities who cannot yet speak (prelinguistic). They applied a technique called 'Responsivity education for the parents and Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching for the children' (RPMT or RE/PMT). Milieu Teaching (MT) targets verbal communicative acts whereas Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching (PMT) targets non-verbal communicative acts (e.g. gestures, vocalisations, eye-contact). Responsivity Education (RE) targets parents participation in responding to children's communication acts. The results showed that child-initiated comments increased for some children but not for others. The authors recommend linguistic goals for communicative children and prelinguistic goals for non-communicative children.
2006: Marc E Fey, Paul J Yoder, Steven F Warren and colleagues studied children with developmental delays using Responsivity Education/Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching (RE/PMT or RPMT). The effects of RE/PMT on children with Down Syndrome found statistically insignificant improvements in overall communication. The study found no differences in parental stress levels. [Although not directly related to RTS, the three papers in this section together with the papers in the previous section should provide useful insights for your child's Speech & Language Therapist/Pathologist. And don't forget that sign language is another language].
2002: Paul J Yoder and Steven F Warren studied children with intellectual disabilities who cannot yet speak (prelinguistic). They applied a technique called 'Responsivity education for the parents and Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching for the children' (RPMT or RE/PMT). Milieu Teaching (MT) targets verbal communicative acts whereas Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching (PMT) targets non-verbal communicative acts (e.g. gestures, vocalisations, eye-contact). Responsivity Education (RE) targets parents participation in responding to children's communication acts. The results showed that child-initiated comments increased for some children but not for others. The authors recommend linguistic goals for communicative children and prelinguistic goals for non-communicative children.
2006: Marc E Fey, Paul J Yoder, Steven F Warren and colleagues studied children with developmental delays using Responsivity Education/Prelinguistic Milieu Teaching (RE/PMT or RPMT). The effects of RE/PMT on children with Down Syndrome found statistically insignificant improvements in overall communication. The study found no differences in parental stress levels. [Although not directly related to RTS, the three papers in this section together with the papers in the previous section should provide useful insights for your child's Speech & Language Therapist/Pathologist. And don't forget that sign language is another language].
Language
2007: Elizabeth Kay-Raining Bird reviews the literature on typical monolingual and bilingual child development compared with bilingual language-impaired children with and without intellectual disabilities (ID) but focussing on Down Syndrome (DS). The research finds that typical children can learn two languages at the same time (simultaneous bilingualism), even at preschool, provided the learning is intensive; there may even be cognitive advantages in doing so. It is normal for both languages to be used in a single utterance. The research is less clear about the effects of learning one language after another (sequential bilingualism) but the author guesses that the results are likely to be similar to simultaneous bilingualism. The author then tries to apply this research to children with ID and DS and concludes that 'it seems appropriate to stop thinking in terms of restricting children with language and intellectual disabilities to a single language and to focus on learning how to best support them in all the languages they need to know. To this end, further research is critical'. I'm therefore optimistic that Maria will learn both English and BSL languages and will then have a choice of which to communicate with when she is older, whether it be English, BSL or Makaton in SSE mode.
Latest Research and Trials
![]() |
| Call that a 'grimace'? |
OrphaNet (EU)
Clinical Trials (US)
Clinical Trials (Worldwide)
The latest EU licensed pharmaceutical (orphan) drugs can be found here:
OrphaNet (EU)
OrphaNews (EU)
I've been warned by a bioethicist that clinical trials are not always conducted as ethically as you might expect in the UK. I have a healthy scepticism of new research and I've promised myself to research the researchers and carefully read the waivers on their contracts before permitting Maria to participate in a clinical trial. If in doubt, I'd probably get some legal advice.
In reality this is a tough choice: I want to help RTS research but on the other hand I don't want Maria harmed by an experimental drug. By the same token I don't want these same risks taken by any other individuals either, so that leads to a bit of a stalemate.
The only way around this is to be rational and understand a bit more about how the research field works. Although there are no specific RTS videos on this topic, there is an excellent summary of the whole field of research from the perspective of Rett Syndrome (RTT) given by Monica Coenraads of the Rett Syndrome Research Trust (RSRT). If you have a spare hour then this will bring you up to speed; so many of the issues in RTT parallel those found in RTS. The video is called 'Curing Rett Syndrome: How Do We Get There?'; just click on the title.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





